Crude Oil Shale and Fuel gas
The present prime concern of politicians is no longer the rapid depletion of the finite reserves of non-renewable combustible resources, such as crude oil, natural gas and coal, but rather the adverse environmental consequences of their utilisation. Oil-shale is one of the largest relatively undeveloped natural, fossil-fuel resources in the world and so an important potential source of energy. It is, in some respects, similar to coal, being a highly-variable solid material with respect to its physical and chemical properties, which dictate the overall processing economics of a commercial-scale plant for its utilisation.
Production of synthetic fuels and/or electricity from oil-shale usually results in discharges of pollutants to the environment. (The waste from a processing plant is often not an unavoidable result of plant operation but a measure of its inefficiency: in general, the more efficient a plant is, the more unusable by-products it produces). The challenge facing the establishment of a commercially-viable oil-shale industry is not only the development of a simple, efficient and low-cost process, but limiting these adverse environmental impacts. This will require an understanding of various technologies for harnessing the energy from the oil-shale, such as mining; its preparation and crushing; retorting; direct combustion; as well as the disposal of spent shale and other wastes in an environmentally-wise manner.
Existing oil-shale deposits world-wide are abundant compared with other remaining fossil-fuel reserves. The availability of crude oil or natural gas can be measured in decades, whereas the identified readily-available oil-shale reserves are sufficient to satisfy the world’s energy needs for several centuries. This should ensure the further development of oil-shale (as an energy source at competitive cost) especially for electric-power generation.
Oil-shale conversion systems are presently at various stages of evolution. They range from those already being used in Estonia, Russia and China, to those currently being tested via pilot (or laboratory) scale projects in Japan, Australia, Morocco and the USA, to those that have been formulated conceptually (but still need to be tested), such as the proposed OSITGS. At present, oil-shale utilisation technologies are limited to either destructive distillation (i.e. retorting) processes to produce shale oil and synthetic gases, or direct combustion for electric-power generation and other industrial purposes.
There are major difficulties facing the development of the oil-shale industry, such as the environmental impacts of the processes involved. For example, in Estonia, employing pulverised oil-shale combustion systems incurs serious operational difficulties, including the low availability of the boilers as a result of corrosion, fouling and slagging (which are enhanced in the presence of alkali metals, sulphates and chlorides in the raw shale) as well as water-, land- and air-pollution problems. The average thermal-efficiency of existing commercial pulverised oil-shale plants is
30% (even without flue-gas clean-up) and they have low availabilities (i.e.
50%). In general, such technology for firing oil-shale is financially discouraging as well as environmentally unacceptable and hazardous. Thus, it has not achieved significant market-penetration world-wide. More stringent emission-control requirements and the need to generate electricity (or heat for industrial processes) from fossil fuels (at higher efficiencies and lower costs) have led to new technologies being introduced (e.g. fluidised bed-combustion, FBC). This is considered to be an energy-efficient and environmentally-friendly means of burning low-grade, high sulphur-content, low calorific-value solid fuels, such as tars; industrial, agricultural and municipal wastes; poor-quality coals; and oil-shale.
Retorting processes (based on heating oil-shale to relatively-high temperatures of
500°C) tend to yield many aromatic-hydrocarbons, which can combine to form carcinogenic compounds, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. This significant health hazard, together with the necessity for the disposal of vast amounts of retorted shale resulting in groundwater contamination, can lead to serious adverse environmental impacts. It appears that most current technologies (except FBC) for utilising oil-shale still pose unanswered challenges.
In this preliminary study, a broad-brush analysis is undertaken deliberately because of the uncertainties concerning the future performances and costs of technologies that will be incorporated into the proposed system. More importantly, the main aim is to draw attention to the expected environmental impacts of the proposed OSITGS and appropriate mitigation measures that can be imagined at present.
The main objective of developing the OSITGS is to reduce Jordan’s dependence on imported crude-oil. This requires the development of an economically-competitive and environmentally-acceptable oil-shale industry, whose products can compete commercially without government subsidies. The proposed basic-plant is a complete facility for mining, retorting, gasification and combustion of the oil-shale, as well as for disposing of the spent shale. The preliminary design of this integrated system is based on proven technologies, such as oil-shale mining and retorting, gas-turbines, waste-heat recovery boilers, circulating fluidised-bed combustors (CFBCs) and ash cooling-and-disposal equipment.
The proposed plant will, most likely, be located close to the vast naturally-occurring oil-shale deposits. It would be capable of processing oil-shale into synthetic fuels and electricity, with a nominal output of
8000 barrels per day of shale oil and 400 MWe of electric-power (as an installed generation capacity). It consists of the following.
Surface (i.e. strip or open-pit) mining will be used. The overburden and the oil-shale are loosened by explosives, and then extracted by draglines and/or shovels. The coarse oil-shale is crushed and transported away from the mine to the processing plant.
These receive and stockpile the crushed shale from the mine and provide surge storage between the mine and the processing units. The coarse shale is crushed and screened to the required size, then separated and stored in various hoppers (which feed the different processes within the plant) according to size.
The gasifier operates at relatively-high temperatures in order to produce the desired low-calorific-value (LCV) fuel gas, which is used to fuel the simple combined-cycle unit. Char from the bottom of the gasifier is fed, together with fine particles collected from the hot fuel-gas clean-up stream, to the CFBC.
The indirectly-heated retort produces shale oil and medium-calorific-value (MCV) fuel gas. Oil vapour and gas are collected and removed from the retort, in order to be cooled and separated. The retorted shale is circulated to the CFBC, so all the combustibles remaining are utilised.
Fine (of average size <6 mm) oil-shale particles and solid waste-streams (e.g. retorted shale and residual char), as well as gaseous and the difficult-to-dispose-of liquid by-products from other processing units, are fed to the CFBC. Superheated high-pressure steam is generated and used to drive a turbine generator to produce electric-power, and to supply the steam required for other processes. Fuel gas produced (from either the retort or gasifier) may be used as a supplemental fuel for ensuring the CFBC’s flame-stability.
These include the raw-water treatment unit, coolers, waste-water treatment plant, spent-ash cooling and disposal system as well as storage and general facilities.
The proposed plant should be established near the oil-shale deposits (i.e. in the central part of Jordan, near Karak), in the region extending from 100 to 150 km south of Amman. The local topography is flat to rolling with some hills: the average elevation is between 700 and 800 m above sea level. The climate there is very hot, dry and dusty in summer and cold and dry in winter, with monthly-average temperatures of
5°C in winter and
37°C in summer. However, the maximum temperature during the summer usually exceeds 40°C. The annual rainfall is normally between 50 and 100 mm, but the amount may vary significantly from year-to-year. Rain storms are localised and floods are comparatively few: hence, it is considered to be a semi-desert area. But there are a few small, shallow dams, which are filled during the rainy season but dry-up towards the end of summer. The prevalent wind is from the south west at 30 (±5) km/h during winter, but occasionally afternoon-wind speeds may reach up to
50 km/h. Whereas the summer wind is predominantly from the north west at lower speeds (i.e. 15 (±5) km/h).
Tags: oil shale


